FAKE, FRAUDULENT RATINGS

How the copycats defrauded AHRI and the public, and how INNOVA caught them.

Fake capacity.
Fake efficiency.

  • Confirmed in INNOVA's laboratory.
  • Certified fake in AHRI's laboratory.
  • Applied Comfort
  • Design Line (Mestek)
  • dubbll
  • Ice Air
  • Islandaire
  • KLIMACOM
  • MRCOOL
  • PMC Green
  • WAYSOS

The copycats were F’ing around with AHRI.

FakeFraudulentFalseForgedFauxFictitiousFabricatedFraudFalsifiedFudged

  • So INNOVA brought in MoFo (Morrison Foerster) to Ferret out the truth.
  • When tested with the real units, the F’ing copycats Failed at AHRI.
  • When you F around with INNOVA, you get F’d in the end.
  • Now the copycats are F’d. Everybody knows their specs are FAKE and FRAUDULENT.

How INNOVA found it

Step 1: Certified copycats

INNOVA found that copycat units of its packaged heat pump design were listed as certified in the AHRI Directory.

Step 2: INNOVA had already tested them

INNOVA had tested the same unit in its own laboratory. It fell far short of the ratings now listed for it. A unit that could not reach those ratings in INNOVA's lab could not have passed AHRI testing as sold.

Step 3: The fan speeds gave it away

The AHRI listings certify cooling airflow above the highest fan speed in the brands' own literature. The production fan cannot deliver the airflow on the certificate.

Step 4: INNOVA brought in MoFo and went to AHRI

INNOVA got its law firm, MoFo (Morrison Foerster), involved and went to AHRI's certification team with its findings.

Step 5: A real unit, not a sample

Instead of a sample supplied by the manufacturer, INNOVA procured a regular production unit from the field, supplied through Syracuse University, and delivered it to Intertek for AHRI testing.

Step 6: The result: FAIL

AHRI tested the production unit taken from Syracuse University, July 17 to October 1, 2026. On October 27, 2026, AHRI delivered the result: fail. The unit sold to consumers did not perform like the sample Nordica submitted for certification.

FAIL

Notice from AHRI's counsel (Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP) to INNOVA's counsel (Morrison & Foerster LLP), October 27, 2026.

AHRI notice of the challenge test result

Illustration. AHRI challenge test result for Design Line MHP10 (AHRI Ref. No. 217626317): FAIL, October 27, 2026.

Different brands. Same unit. Same test. Same fraud.

All these units were caught cheating and defrauding AHRI with fake data.

NORDICA BASE MODELS

YWD-10HD115VYWD-10HD2208V

Every listing below is built off these two Nordica units.

  • Applied Comfort

    5 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    TPHE10L00E6A30 · TPHE10L00E6A31 · TPHE10K10E6A30 · TPHE10K10E6A31 · TPHE10K20E7A31

  • Design Line (Mestek)

    2 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    MHP10 · MHP11 · unit tested by AHRI

  • dubbll

    3 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    DDHPA10X00E · DDHPA-12Y-10E · DDHPA-12Y-20E

  • Islandaire

    3 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    EZMB10L5A1S95AA · EZMB10L2O1S95AA · EZMB10L9A1S95AA

  • KLIMACOM

    4 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    ND-10H1 · ND1-10H1 · ND-10H2 · ND1-10H2

  • MRCOOL

    1 LISTING

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    MDM10115D

  • PMC Green

    1 LISTING

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    PMCG-YWD-10HD/FC-3-W

  • WAYSOS

    3 LISTINGS

    FAILED FRAUDULENT DATA

    CAPRO0010K115V · CAPRO1K10K208V · CAPRO2K10K208V

  • Ice Air

    1 LISTING

    SAME UNIT

    iCool XC 8RSXC09-DH · Ref. 217048832
    Listed separately at 8,100 Btu/h · marked "Discontinued" 06-23-2025 while sold

One manufacturer. One test.

Nordica tested the unit; the result was listed for eight brands. Private-brand listings mirror the manufacturer's ratings without separate testing (AHRI GOM §§ 5.2.2, 11.3).

The golden sample

This is how these fraudulent listings were made. A golden sample is a unit built for the certification test that does not match the unit sold under the same model number.

Step 1: Build a special unit

A unit is prepared for testing with a more powerful fan and one or more of: larger coils, a different compressor, larger openings or a different cabinet.

Step 2: Submit it under the production model number

The special unit is sent to the lab as if it were the model sold to customers.

Step 3: It passes and gets listed

The test results become the certified ratings in the AHRI Directory.

Step 4: Nordica uploads the result for every brand

The ratings from Nordica's test are listed for eight brands — 22 listings — with no brand's production unit tested.

Step 5: Customers receive a different unit

Engineers, code officials, incentive programs and owners rely on ratings the installed unit does not deliver.

What the AHRI test showed.

Nordica's certification sample passed. The production unit taken from Syracuse University, the same model sold to consumers, failed. The two cannot be the same unit. Nordica submitted a specially made sample to pass the test, and that sample is not the unit sold on the market.

UNIT TESTED FOR CERTIFICATION

  • Fan above the production maximum
  • Airflow 360–405 scfm
  • Ratings listed in the AHRI Directory

UNIT SOLD TO CUSTOMERS

  • Production fan, 305–311 CFM maximum
  • Same model number
  • Failed AHRI challenge test

Fake airflow

Capacity, EER2, SEER2 and HSPF2 are all measured at the certified airflow. A unit whose fan cannot move that air cannot produce those ratings.

Every AHRI test point exceeds its fan speed

Design Line's brochure lists three cooling fan speeds. Each test point is matched to the fan speed that runs it.

+109%

Low fan speed vs Minimum test point

BROCHURE194 CFM
AHRI LISTING405 scfm

+46%

Medium fan speed vs Intermediate test point

BROCHURE277 CFM
AHRI LISTING405 scfm

+16%

High fan speed vs Full-load test point

BROCHURE311 CFM
AHRI LISTING360 scfm

Brochure: Design Line Roommate RMM-4, cooling CFM. AHRI: listing Ref. No. 217626317 (MHP10), cooling air volume, scfm. At the AHRI cooling test condition 1 scfm = 1.027 CFM, so the gaps in actual airflow are larger than shown.

What INNOVA did

Reviewed. Reported. Tested.

FAIL

OCTOBER 27, 2026
Results delivered: FAIL

  1. STEP 1

    Data review

    INNOVA compared each brand's literature with its AHRI listing and found certified airflow above the brands' own published maximum.

  2. STEP 2

    INNOVA consults MoFo

    INNOVA consults its law firm, MoFo (Morrison Foerster), on what to do about this blatant cheating at AHRI.

  3. STEP 3

    Findings presented to AHRI

    INNOVA brought the discrepancies to AHRI's certification team.

  4. JULY 16, 2026

    Production unit delivered for testing

    At AHRI's request, INNOVA arranged for Syracuse University to supply a production Design Line MHP10 from the field. It was delivered to Intertek.

  5. JULY 17, 2026

    AHRI testing begins

    AHRI begins testing the production unit in the Intertek laboratory.

  6. OCTOBER 1, 2026

    Laboratory testing completed

    Testing of the production unit is completed.

  7. OCTOBER 4, 2026

    Full technical file submitted

    INNOVA submitted its analysis of all 17 listings to AHRI, with supporting exhibits.

  8. OCTOBER 27, 2026

    Results delivered: FAIL

    AHRI reported the final outcome of the challenge test on the Design Line MHP10: fail. The 22 listings built on the same Nordica test fail with it.

  9. BY NOVEMBER 10, 2026

    Directory update

    AHRI to update the affected ratings in its Directory.

The AHRI certificates

AHRI Certificates of Product Ratings for each listing, retrieved October 28, 2026 (Ice Air: April 22, 2026).

1 / 18

APPLIED COMFORT

TPHE10K10E6A30 · AHRI REF. 218745183

The AHRI certificates
BrandModelAHRI Ref. No.
Applied ComfortTPHE10K10E6A30218745183
Applied ComfortTPHE10K10E6A31218745184
Applied ComfortTPHE10K20E7A31218745185
Applied ComfortTPHE10L00E6A30218745186
Applied ComfortTPHE10L00E6A31218745187
Design LineMHP10217626317
Design LineMHP11217626318
dubbllDDHPA-12Y-10E218743572
dubbllDDHPA-12Y-20E218743573
dubbllDDHPA10X00E218743574
Ice Air8RSXC09-DH217048832
IslandaireEZMB10L5A1S95AA218722967
IslandaireEZMB10L9A1S95AA218722968
MRCOOLMDM10115D218743763
PMC GreenPMCG-YWD-10HD/FC-3-W218731299
WAYSOSCAPRO1K10K208V218810460
WAYSOSCAPRO2K10K208V218810461
WAYSOSCAPRO0010K115V218810462
Read the full report